A Structural Analysis of Public Export Incentives: Institutional Diversity, Bureaucratic Barriers and Entrepreneurs' Expectations
The Republic of Türkiye continues to pursue an export-led growth strategy with unwavering determination in order to preserve macroeconomic stability and the balance of foreign trade. To this end, public authorities have built a broad institutional network to encourage and support exports through numerous institutions and organisations, including the Ministry of Trade, Türk Eximbank, KOSGEB, TÜBİTAK, the Ministry of Industry and Technology, the Development Agencies, the Development and Investment Bank of Türkiye, the Turkish Exporters Assembly (TİM) and the Exporters' Associations. In theory, this institutional diversity aims to make it easier for firms of every size to find a suitable support instrument.
The Ministry of Trade's State Aid Guide lists no fewer than 77 types of support under headings such as support for companies, support for cooperation organisations, state aid for e-exports, the distant countries strategy, state aid for service exports and Eximbank/İGE A.Ş. programmes. This pool of incentives is complemented by other financial and administrative facilities such as the Inward Processing Regime (DİR), the Outward Processing Regime (HİR), VAT exemptions, corporate tax exemptions and Free Zone privileges (customs duty exemption, income tax withholding support, corporate tax exemption, special consumption tax exemption, property and stamp duty exemptions, etc.).
Despite this institutional and structural richness, however, the literature and data collected in the field reveal significant structural problems and mismatches that limit the effectiveness of the current incentive system. According to the common findings of the scientific studies conducted, the main problems entrepreneurs face when trying to benefit from public incentives are as follows:
- Complex Legislation and Procedures: Highly bureaucratic application processes, extensive documentation requirements and complicated application steps prevent SMEs with limited managerial capacity in particular from accessing support.
- Institutional Fragmentation: The large number of implementing bodies offering incentives, and the lack of sufficient integration between them, lead to information overload and confusion over responsibilities.
- Frequently Changing Legislation: Frequent changes to the rules and procedures governing incentives and state aid make long-term strategic planning difficult for entrepreneurs.
- Focus on Large Firms: Existing policy instruments are designed to support the production and export processes of large firms that already enjoy economies of scale, rather than start-ups that make risky and innovative investments.
To achieve the export model envisaged in the Twelfth Development Plan, based on advanced technology, supported by quality financing and creating maximum employment, it is essential to resolve these shortcomings and revise the incentive system in line with entrepreneurs' expectations. In this context, the shared recommendation of the field and the literature is to reduce the number of implementing bodies and bring incentives together in a single-window system, radically simplify bureaucratic procedures, make changes to incentives less frequent and more predictable, and ultimately design flexible financial support modules specifically for foreign trade entrepreneurs who produce high value added.