A Paradigm Shift in Public Incentives: From Volume-Based Support to a Value-Added and Entrepreneurship-Oriented Model
For many years the Republic of Türkiye has pursued an export-led growth strategy to support macroeconomic stability and development. To this end, public authorities have designed an extremely broad and comprehensive incentive mechanism through institutions such as the Ministry of Trade, Türk Eximbank, the Development Agencies, KOSGEB, TÜBİTAK, the Ministry of Industry and Technology and the Turkish Exporters Assembly (TİM). The Ministry of Trade's State Aid Guide, for instance, lists 77 different types of support under headings such as support for companies, support for cooperation organisations, e-export support and Eximbank programmes. This wide range is complemented by the Inward Processing Regime (DİR), the Outward Processing Regime (HİR), VAT exemptions, corporate tax exemptions and Free Zone incentives.
However, the literature review and the data collected in the field show that existing incentive instruments focus on directly increasing export volume (in quantity terms) rather than on the innovative investments that would secure a lasting competitive advantage. The drive to increase exports purely in quantity delays the technological deepening of firms at the micro level and pushes the production of high value-added goods into the background, bringing standard and traditional products to the fore.
More importantly, existing support instruments are by nature better suited to supporting the production and export processes of large firms that already enjoy economies of scale. As a result, new-generation ventures (start-ups and dynamic SMEs) that carry high financial risk at the outset but produce innovative, high value-added products cannot benefit sufficiently from public resources. Innovative product support offered by institutions such as KOSGEB and TÜBİTAK largely remains at the level of import substitution and fails to create a disruptive competitive advantage in global markets.
The international literature has also shown that the effect of public institutional networks and support on SMEs' international entrepreneurial activity differs radically by firm size. Reaching the goal set out in the Twelfth Development Plan, "an economic model based on advanced technology, producing high value added, supported by quality financing and creating maximum employment", requires a holistic paradigm shift in the incentive system. New-generation incentive policies should simplify bureaucratic procedures, change legislation less frequently, reduce the number of implementing bodies and be equipped with flexible instruments that directly target the "foreign trade entrepreneur".